Business

Your Top Performer Just Got Promoted. Here’s Why That Might Be a Mistake.

Reading in data-saving mode. Read full article from Entrepreneur website.

Published 10/21/2026 12:00:00 PM

Your Top Performer Got Promoted. That Might Be a Mistake.

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

Key Takeaways

Being a top performer doesn’t automatically make someone a good manager. Before you promote, walk the candidate through what the role actually requires, and ask directly whether they still want it.
Separate recognition from promotion. Consider rewarding strong employees with higher pay, more ownership or other opportunities rather than promoting them into a role they may not want or be suited for.
Give candidates real decision-making responsibilities to assess their readiness. If they want the job and aren’t fully ready but could grow into it, provide mentoring and training to prepare them.

Earlier this year, Meta began laying off roughly 8,000 employees as part of a restructuring the company described internally as “AI native,” flattening its management layers and reorganizing teams into smaller, faster-moving pods. The company’s Chief People Officer told staff that many teams could now operate with a leaner structure and fewer managers overseeing more ownership per person. The management layer itself was being redesigned out of the org chart, regardless of how those managers had performed.

That should give any leader pause before promoting their next star performer into a management role. There used to be room to get a promotion wrong. A struggling new manager could be quietly reassigned, or the org chart could absorb one bad fit without much notice. That room is shrinking. When companies are actively cutting the number of management slots available, the ones that remain carry more weight — a mis-promotion can cost the team a layer of leadership it may not get another shot at building.

I’ve coached executive teams across a dozen industries, and I see this mistake repeated more than almost any other. A company promotes its best individual performer into a leadership role, and performance drops on both sides. The star feels lost, the team feels misled, and nobody stops to ask the one question that would have prevented it: Is this person actually ready to lead the people who do the work, or are they just exceptional at doing the work themselves?

Those are two different things, and organizations routinely conflate them. Good work is rewarded with the wrong reward, or real leadership potential is promoted for the wrong reasons. Here’s a framework for separating the two before you make the call:

1. Ask if they actually want the job

Most companies test whether someone is talented enough to lead. Almost none test whether they want to. That gap matters more than it may seem. According to Gartner research published in Harvard Business Review, roughly one in four managers say they’d prefer not to be people managers at all, and most had little exposure beforehand — through simulations, mentorship or similar previews — to gauge whether the role actually suited them before they were promoted into it.

A high performer who says yes to a promotion is often saying yes to the recognition, not the job description underneath it. By the time anyone notices the difference, the team has already absorbed the cost. Before you promote, walk the candidate through what the role actually requires day to day — managing conflict, owning other people’s failures, sitting in meetings instead of doing the work they’re good at — and ask directly whether they still want it. If the honest answer is hesitation, that’s information, not a red flag to ignore.

Most organizations treat promotion as their only lever for telling someone they matter, and that’s the root of the succession trap. James Deng, CEO of Poké House, has run into this firsthand while scaling the fast-casual restaurant chain. “I’ve learned that you have to separate recognition from promotion,” Deng told me. “Sometimes the right answer is to pay someone more, give them more ownership or find another way for them to grow without putting them into a role that doesn’t fit them.”

Deng put the stakes even more plainly: “The goal shouldn’t just be to move your best people up. It should be to put your best people in positions where they can continue to be their best.”

3. Test decision-making before the title changes

I coach leaders to run one exercise before finalizing any promotion to a leadership role, which is to give the candidate a real decision — one with actual stakes — and let them own it while they’re still an individual contributor. Not a hypothetical. A live budget call, a hiring decision, a conflict between two team members that needs resolving. Watch what they do when the answer isn’t obvious.

I’ve seen candidates who were flawless at the technical work freeze the moment the decision required trading off one person’s needs against another’s. And I’ve seen quieter performers step into that same test with a clarity that told me everything I needed to know. The work reveals whether someone can execute. This exercise reveals whether they can lead. Run it before the promotion, and you’ll know which one you’re actually looking at.

4. If they want it and could grow into it, coach them first

The exercise above sorts candidates into two groups: the ones who are ready now and the ones who aren’t. The second group is where most leaders get it wrong. Not every “not ready yet” is a “no.” Some candidates genuinely want the role and show real flashes of the judgment it requires, but they just haven’t built the muscle yet. That’s not a disqualifier. It’s a development plan with a measurable payoff.

Gallup found that frontline supervisors who completed supervisor-focused training in the past year were 79% more likely to be engaged, 19% less likely to report frequent burnout and 11% less likely to be job hunting.

That gap between trained and untrained supervisors is the whole argument for treating readiness as something you build, not something you check for. Too many leaders treat it as a light switch anyway: on or off, promote or pass. It’s not. Give that candidate a mentor who’s already done the job. Hand them a slice of real leadership — a hiring decision, a budget call or a project of their own — while they’re still an individual contributor, so the stakes stay contained and the learning stays real.

Do this well, and you’ve de-risked the promotion before you’ve made it. Skip it, and you risk losing your best performer twice, once as an individual contributor and once as a manager.

These checks take an afternoon, while a bad promotion takes months to unwind, if it gets unwound at all. That math used to be forgiving, but it isn’t anymore. As companies keep cutting the number of management layers they’re willing to carry, every remaining seat becomes a decision with less room for error and fewer places to hide a wrong one.

Your best performer might still be exactly the leader you need. But “exceptional at the job” and “ready to lead the people doing it” are two different measurements, and only one of them shows up in a performance review. Getting succession right starts with refusing to assume the two are the same thing — and testing for both instead.

The next time a seat opens up, don’t ask who’s earned it. Ask who’s ready for it. Then find out if the answer is the same person.

Key Takeaways

Being a top performer doesn’t automatically make someone a good manager. Before you promote, walk the candidate through what the role actually requires, and ask directly whether they still want it.
Separate recognition from promotion. Consider rewarding strong employees with higher pay, more ownership or other opportunities rather than promoting them into a role they may not want or be suited for.
Give candidates real decision-making responsibilities to assess their readiness. If they want the job and aren’t fully ready but could grow into it, provide mentoring and training to prepare them.

Effective product pages help online shoppers decide whether an item fits their needs and what buying it involves. A beautiful photograph gets attention. Product details such as dimensions, available sizes, delivery details, and a clear price help turn that attention into a purchase.

Even established retailers miss these basics. In its benchmark of leading U.S. and European retailers, updated in March 2026, Baymard Institute rated 52% of desktop sites and 62% of mobile sites “mediocre or worse” for product-page usability¹.

Product-page changes can affect revenue, too. In a 27-day test for Life Pro Fitness, agency Media Contour made product images, key details, and buying buttons visible without needing to scroll. Testing vendor Wingify reported that the revised page generated $0.67 more revenue per visitor than the original².

If you are building a new store, follow the five tips below as you create your product pages. Have those pages ready before running ads that send shoppers to them.

If you already have an online store, choose one product page to improve. Reference these steps to check whether it answers shoppers’ questions and lets them add the right item to their cart.

1. Answer shoppers’ questions in the product description

Identify the main question a shopper needs answered before buying. Look for questions customers ask repeatedly or misunderstandings behind returns. For a new product, start with fit, compatibility, or what is included. Confirm the answer against your product specifications, then put it near the start of the description.

For example, consider a pet-supply retailer selling a dog harness. Someone choosing their first harness needs measurements and adjustment details to judge the fit. Someone replacing a harness they already own needs to recognize the same model and size. The page should make both tasks straightforward.

Also, use consistent labels and units across similar products to make comparisons easier. Include limitations, such as incompatible models or items sold separately, so shoppers can rule out an unsuitable purchase.

In e-commerce platform BigCommerce, for instance, online sellers can use the product description and custom fields—additional facts such as material or compatibility—to present these details. Preview the product page to check that shoppers can find the information they need.

Then, use those same facts to help shoppers recognize the item in search results. In BigCommerce’s page title field, use the product name and a relevant detail, such as its model or material. Avoid repeating keywords or giving every product the same title.

2. Give every product image a question to answer

Plan your gallery around what someone needs to inspect. Show the whole product, a useful detail, and the product in use. For example, a lighting retailer could photograph a lamp beside a chair to show its scale and how it lights a reading space. A close-up of the switch shows how someone would operate it. Together, these images help shoppers picture using the lamp at home. Keep written dimensions available as well.

The same Baymard overview describes how shoppers use images to judge size and can struggle when photographs lack a familiar reference.

If you sell a bundle, make clear which pictured items are included. For products that need assembly or demonstration, you might even consider creating a short video. Add alt text: a short description of the useful information in an image. Screen-reader software can read that description aloud or present it in braille. Keep essential instructions available as text as well.

BigCommerce supports product images, images for variants such as different colors, and YouTube-hosted product videos. Check that your gallery presents the right item as shoppers change their selection.

3. Make choices, prices, and recurring charges clear

Keep size, color, quantity, and purchase options close to the buying button. Label them plainly, show the current selection, and make unavailable choices recognizable. If the size options fit on the screen, show them as labeled buttons, such as S, M, and L. This lets shoppers see which sizes are available without opening a menu, as the Baymard overview explains.

Place helpful links beside the choice it explains. For the dog harness, for example, consider putting a measurement guide beside the size selector so shoppers can check the fit before choosing. Keep it visible or provide a clearly labeled link that works by touch and keyboard.

In BigCommerce, online sellers can configure choices such as size and color through product variants and options. Then check that the displayed price and availability match the shopper’s selection. For multipacks, show both the pack total and the unit price. Make the full pack price easy to find so shoppers know what they will be charged.

If you offer subscriptions, let shoppers explicitly choose between a one-time purchase and a recurring order. Put the recurring charge, delivery frequency, and change or cancellation terms beside that choice so shoppers can compare the commitments before selecting. Confirm that these terms match how your subscription service works. Select a subscription yourself and verify that checkout shows the plan, price, and frequency you chose.

4. Make sure delivery, returns, and reviews are easy to find

A shopper who needs an item by a particular date wants to know whether it will arrive in time. Show a delivery estimate for their destination. Put a short explanation of shipping and returns near add to cart, with links to the full policies.

Show shipping fees or explain how they will be calculated. Clearly describe return windows, fees, and exclusions that matter for the item. If pickup is offered, distinguish stock at the selected location from stock elsewhere. Avoid presenting an estimate as a confirmed promise.

Also consider making reassurances that are specific to the purchase. Using the dog harness as an example again, you’d want to explain whether a shopper can exchange it if the fit is wrong and which conditions apply. That answers the practical concerns that a badge saying “Shop with Confidence” leaves unresolved. Use only promises your business can honor.

Customer reviews provide another way to assess the product. Show the review rating, text, reviewer’s display name, and date on the relevant product page. If reviews come from another service, name that service. These details help shoppers understand whose experience they are reading and how recent it is.

5. Test the path from product page to cart

Shoppers need to know that the page has registered their choices and whether adding an item succeeded. Open your chosen product page on your phone. If a required option starts unselected, try adding the item before choosing it. The page should tell you what to select or explain why “Add to cart” is unavailable.

If the product has options, choose them, then change one selection. Check that the price, availability, and any option-specific images match. Add the item. While the request is processing, the page should make that clear. Once it succeeds, a confirmation or the cart itself should show what was added. If an error occurs, it should explain how to continue without losing other selections.

From there, make sure to check the item’s quantity, options, and price in the cart. If you chose a size or color, return to the product page and check whether it still shows that selection. These checks help catch a wrong selection or an uncertain result before a shopper encounters it.

Shoppers who cannot use a mouse need to select options and add products using a keyboard. To check that they can, repeat the steps above on a computer without the mouse. Use Tab to move forward between controls and Shift+Tab to move back. A visible outline or other marker should show which control you are about to use. Press Enter to activate links and Enter or Space for buttons. In a drop-down list, such as a size selector, use the arrow keys to move through the options.

Shoppers who need larger text must still be able to read product details and reach Add to cart. Use the browser’s Zoom control to enlarge the page to 200% and try the same steps again. Check for overlapping text or controls that disappear. Across all these checks, record anything that prevents choosing the product, adding it, or correcting a mistake.

Keep improving one page at a time

Clear facts and images help shoppers judge the product; clear choices, terms, and working controls help them act on that decision. Choose one issue from your review to fix first. Give priority to a problem that prevents adding the correct item to the cart. If shoppers can add the correct item, address an unanswered question that could lead someone to buy the wrong product.

Record what you changed and when. If you have sales reports, compare purchases and revenue for the product over equal periods before and after the change. Note any promotions or changes in visitor numbers that could also explain the results. Customer questions, order corrections, and return reasons can help you check whether the same misunderstanding persists.

For more examples, explore BigCommerce’s product-page guide, then apply the same review to the next product page.

¹^{Product Page UX 2026: 10 Pitfalls and Best Practices}^{(Baymard Institute)
2}^{Media Contour uses split URL testing to improve the revenue from product pages}^(Wingify)